Is Creative Genius Geographical?

From a review of The Geography of Genius by Eric Weiner in The Wall Street Journal: “Why is it that genius isn’t equally distributed over time and place but rather flares up briefly in certain places and then disappears again? … The Athenians abhorred professionalism. Soldiers were poets, and poets were politicians. This led to an extraordinary cross-fertilization of ideas and talents quite alien to our era of hyperspecialization. In Hangzhou … Chinese genius, unlike the Greek or Austrian kind, was free of metaphysical anguish. The Chinese reveled in painting, writing, invention and adventure as the Europeans staggered out of the Middle Ages, and they seemed to thoroughly enjoy themselves.”

“Athens honored wisdom and got Socrates. Rome honored power and got an empire. The 19th-century Viennese honored high culture and the life of the mind and got Beethoven and Freud. Today wealthy patrons in fleece vests pay tens of thousands of dollars to watch alleged geniuses give 17-minute accounts of their work at TED conferences. They support medical research and plans to improve education. They are seeking ways to prolong and enrich human life for more people. This might not yield us the Sistine Chapel, but it may be as worthwhile.”


Your Thoughts?